Why was Carly Smithson voted off of American Idol
I was probably more stunned when Carly Smithson was voted off of American Idol than when Michael Johns was voted off. I mean, c’mon. She is one fantastic looking chic and one heck of a singer. I think America got it wrong when they voted Carly Smithson off of American Idol. Obviously she was the judge’s favorite also. And since they have way more experience picking winners than does the crowd, I’d say they were right when they wanted her to win American Idol. You can bet you haven’t seen the last of Carly Smithson. She’ll be a big star one day and everyone will look back and say "Darn, I wish I hadn’t voted for her to leave when she was on American Idol".